No community start suggestion yet.
Why does Hillel see a floating skull and declare both that it drowned because it drowned someone, and that its killers will also drown? The shiur develops the principle that divine justice measures not just the act but the character trait behind it - drowning shows additional cruelty beyond murder. This leads to a transformative yesod: since divine Providence ensures we only get what we deserve, every negative experience should prompt self-examination rather than just seeking revenge.
This shiur examines a profound Mishna in Pirkei Avos where Hillel sees a skull floating on water and declares that it drowned because it had drowned someone, and that those who drowned it will also drown. The speaker addresses several fundamental questions: How did the first person drown if drowning comes as punishment for drowning others? Why not just state the principle of measure-for-measure directly? The analysis begins with the story of Dovid and Bathsheba, where the prophet Nathan tells Dovid a parable about a rich man stealing a poor man's only sheep. The speaker explains that Dovid's sin wasn't technically adultery (since Bathsheba was divorced as was customary for soldiers' wives), but rather the cruelty of taking from Uriah the one thing he treasured when Dovid, as king, had access to anything he wanted. This introduces the first major principle: there are two levels to every sin - the technical illegality and the character deficiency revealed by how one commits it. Stealing from the poor demonstrates far greater cruelty than stealing from the wealthy, even though both are forbidden. The speaker explains that when human courts judge, they focus on the legal category of the crime. But when God executes justice (midah k'neged midah), He measures not just the act but the character - 'midah' meaning both measure and character trait. Someone who drowns a victim doesn't just kill but also denies them proper burial, revealing additional heartlessness that merits harsher divine punishment. The Tosafot's question about why divine punishment differs from court punishment is thus resolved: courts judge acts, God judges character. The second transformative principle emerges: nothing can happen to anyone that they don't deserve. The person who punishes still gets punished for taking justice into their own hands, but the victim deserved what happened. This means when someone insults, cheats, or hurts us, instead of focusing entirely on revenge, we should primarily examine what we did to deserve this treatment and how we can improve ourselves. The speaker shares a story of a great rabbi who, upon hearing congregants say 'he hates us,' realized the accusation was true and used it for self-improvement. The message is that divine Providence ensures we only receive what we deserve, making every negative experience a opportunity for growth and self-reflection rather than merely seeking retaliation.
Dedicate a Shiur in Aggadita
L'ilui nishmas a loved one. In honor of a simcha or yahrzeit. As a zechus for a refuah sheleimah. Your dedication helps carry Rabbi Zweig's Torah to learners around the world.
Up Next in this Series
How did the first person drown if Hillel says drowning comes from having drowned someone? The shiur develops that divine justice operates differently from human courts - punishing not just the act but the character deficiency it reveals. Since nothing happens to anyone undeserved, our primary response to suffering should be self-examination rather than revenge.
How long must Hashem tolerate the Jewish people's rebellious behavior? A Midrash compares this to the halachic question of carrying a child holding muktze on Shabbos. The analysis reveals that rejecting Eretz Yisrael represents a deeper spiritual corruption than individual acts of avoda zara.
Pirkei Avos 2:6
Looking for the full transcript?
Full access is available to members of the TUF Alumni Association or the Yam Hagadol Foundation.
Already a member? Let the admin know!
How can divine justice be reconciled with the idea that bad things happen to good people? Unlike earthly courts that only punish by taking away, heavenly justice operates through love—God removes impediments to give us more. Even a 99% righteous person may experience difficulties to address that remaining 1%, ensuring maximum eternal reward rather than letting small imperfections cost them in the world to come.
What did Dovid mean when he reduced the 613 mitzvos to twelve principles? The Gemara reveals that mitzvos have two dimensions: fulfilling the obligation and achieving personal completion (hashlomah). Dovid identified twelve core principles that encapsulate the essential character development aspect of all mitzvos.
