An exploration of why people violate Shmitah laws despite having adequate provisions, revealing that humans fundamentally need purposeful work - and how Torah (תורה) study must fulfill this need during the sabbatical year.
This shiur addresses a fundamental question about the Shmitah year: why do people violate its laws even when they've been provided for in advance? Rashi (רש"י) explains that the Torah (תורה)'s curses come from not being 'amal b'Torah' (toiling in Torah), but the text also indicates that exile results from violating Shmitah. The speaker reconciles this apparent contradiction by exploring the deeper psychology of human motivation. The key insight centers on the Talmudic principle 'Adam l'amal yulad' - humans are born to work. The Gemara (גמרא) discusses three types of necessary labor: amal melacha (physical work), amal sichah (social interaction), and amal Torah (Torah study). These correspond to different aspects of human nature - the body needs physical work, the soul (nefesh) needs social connection, and the divine soul (neshamah) needs Torah study. During the six working years, farmers engage primarily in physical labor while also learning Torah. In the seventh year (Shmitah), they must transition to making Torah study their primary form of 'work.' If someone hasn't developed the ability to find fulfillment through Torah study, they will feel empty and compelled to return to physical work - not because they need the produce (having been provided for), but because humans cannot psychologically tolerate inactivity. The speaker illustrates this with examples of retirement, noting that retirees who don't engage in meaningful learning often become desperate for any activity to fill their time, even volunteer positions far beneath their former status. Those who successfully transition to intensive Torah study, however, find genuine fulfillment. This connects to a deeper life trajectory: as people age and their physical capacities diminish, they should ideally transition toward finding their primary fulfillment through Torah study. The ultimate goal is achieving 'menucha' (rest) - not physical idleness, but the ability to find complete fulfillment through spiritual and intellectual pursuits rather than physical creativity. The Mishnah (משנה)'s teaching that 'if one is idle from Torah, there are many idle pursuits' is reinterpreted: when people lack meaningful fulfillment through Torah, they expand trivial activities to fill the psychological vacuum. Busy, fulfilled people accomplish more because they don't need to manufacture artificial time-fillers. As we approach Shavuot, the message is clear: Torah learning should not merely be about acquiring knowledge, but about finding life's primary fulfillment. When Torah study becomes one's main source of purpose and accomplishment, other necessary activities take their proper proportion, and the person can truly 'rest' during designated times without feeling empty or compelled to violate spiritual boundaries.
Rabbi Zweig challenges Freudian psychology by arguing that the basic human drive is not pleasure-seeking but rather the painful awareness of non-existence, and explains how only a relationship with God can provide the feeling of true existence and simcha.
An exploration of the deeper meaning of 'amirah' (saying) as empowering others by recognizing their uniqueness and building meaningful relationships through authentic, individualized communication.
Parshas Bechukosai
Sign in to access full transcripts
