Chanukah and the Crown of Shem Tov: Defining Your Own Standard

Rabbi Zweig opens by noting that the Gemara (גמרא) in Yoma teaches that three crowns correspond to three vessels in the Temple: the crown of Torah (תורה) (the Aron), the crown of Kehuna (the Mizbeach), and the crown of Malchus (the Shulchan). A Midrash in Parshas Naso identifies a fourth crown—Keser Shem Tov, the crown of a good name—with the menorah. This raises a question: if Chanukah (חנוכה) centers on lighting the menorah, what does Chanukah have to do with acquiring a Shem Tov, a good name? What does "a good name" actually mean, and is it something we should strive for—constantly thinking about what others think of us? Rabbi Zweig proposes that the Gemara in Yoma offers a profound definition of Shem Tov. The Gemara states that Hillel will be mechayav (obligate/indict) the poor person, Rabbi Elazar ben Charsum will be mechayav the wealthy person, and Yosef HaTzadik will be mechayav everyone else. The simple meaning: if a poor person claims he was too poor to learn Torah, God will point to Hillel, who was extraordinarily poor yet still learned. If a wealthy person claims he was too busy managing his affairs, God will point to Rabbi Elazar ben Charsum, who owned hundreds of cities yet devoted himself to Torah. If anyone claims they couldn't control their desires, God will point to Yosef, who resisted the wife of Potiphar under the most difficult circumstances.