Rabbi Zweig explores why God didn't create angels on the first day of creation and why He prefers human partnership over angelic partnership in building the Mishkan.
Rabbi Zweig begins by analyzing a puzzling aspect of creation: why is the first day called "yom echad" (day one) using a cardinal number, while subsequent days use ordinal numbers (second, third)? Rashi (רש"י) explains this indicates God was "one" and alone that day, as angels weren't created until the second day. The Midrash presents an apparent contradiction - first stating God didn't want partners (hence no angels on day one), then saying God always wanted partners and rectified this on the day the Mishkan was established, changing "yom echad" to "yom rishon." The resolution lies in understanding the fundamental difference between angels and humans as partners. Angels, despite having limited free choice according to Rambam (רמב"ם), are programmed for specific functions and act primarily for self-expression. When angels perform their designated roles (like Refael healing), they're fulfilling their essential nature - doing what satisfies them most. This creates a partnership problem because they perceive themselves as contributors to God's work, making them dangerous partners who might claim "we destroyed" (as the angels said regarding Sodom). The progression of angelic involvement in Torah (תורה) shows this dynamic clearly. Initially, angels participated in man's creation ("na'aseh adam") and served as God's cabinet. However, after Abraham's emergence, particularly following brit milah, the dynamic shifted. Angels began serving the patriarchs rather than being God's primary advisors, as seen when they came to Abraham and later when Jacob sent angels as messengers. Humans, by contrast, have genuine free choice and can choose alternatives that seem more personally fulfilling. When humans serve God despite having more appealing options, they demonstrate true self-sacrifice and devotion to God rather than self-expression. This is exemplified by Nachshon ben Aminadav jumping into the Sea of Reeds - he understood that following God's command ("move forward") might mean death, but chose obedience over self-preservation. The Mishkan represents the perfection of this dynamic. While Israelites performed all the physical labor (more than angels would have done in creation), they did so not for self-expression or to display their craftsmanship, but purely from desire to be close to God. This makes them safe partners - they won't claim equality because they recognize they're acting solely for God's sake. Bezalel, the Mishkan's architect, possessed the same creative letters used for heaven and earth, yet this power wasn't dangerous because it was exercised with complete devotion. This explains why God can entrust humans with tremendous power (kingship, priesthood, blessings) without concern. Like Abraham trusting Eliezer with finding Isaac's wife, God can delegate authority to those whose sole motivation is serving their master. The ten crowns given on the day the Mishkan was established represent various forms of power God could safely grant to devoted servants. The shiur concludes that true partnership with God requires the ability to act for God's sake rather than self-expression, which only beings with genuine free choice can achieve.
Rabbi Zweig challenges Freudian psychology by arguing that the basic human drive is not pleasure-seeking but rather the painful awareness of non-existence, and explains how only a relationship with God can provide the feeling of true existence and simcha.
An exploration of the deeper meaning of 'amirah' (saying) as empowering others by recognizing their uniqueness and building meaningful relationships through authentic, individualized communication.
Midrash Bereishit Rabbah on Creation
Sign in to access full transcripts
