A profound exploration of why Rosh Hashanah is called a day of judgment yet focuses on proclaiming God's kingship rather than examining individual sins, revealing the true purpose of creation and our relationship with the Divine.
This shiur addresses fundamental questions about the nature of Rosh Hashanah that seem paradoxical. Why is it called Yom Teruah (day of the shofar blast) - a war cry - yet described as a day of friendship with God? Why is there no formal teshuvah (repentance) in the liturgy despite it being Yom HaDin? Most puzzling, why does someone with capital offenses walk free if they have more mitzvos than aveiros - what kind of judgment is this? The answer lies in understanding a fundamental Gemara (גמרא) about creation itself. Originally, God planned to create the world with pure midas hadin (divine justice) - strict quid pro quo judgment. But He saw the world couldn't survive this way, so He joined midas harachamim (divine mercy). This wasn't merely tempering justice with mercy, but rather creating an entirely different relationship structure between God and humanity. In the original plan of midas hadin, man would have been created as a separate entity whose sole purpose was to coronate God as king - the only thing humans can do for the Divine. But this system was doomed because the only motivation would be self-interest (to earn existence), and any system based purely on self-interest ultimately fails. Moreover, man would have power over God in that moment of choosing whether to coronate Him, creating perverse incentives. Instead, God created man with midas harachamim, meaning He created us as His children, not just subjects. Adam was given a neshamah from God's own essence, establishing a father-son relationship. This changes everything: a son has motivation to serve his father not just from self-interest (becoming a prince when the father is king), but from love and relationship. A son can do things simply because the father wants them done. This explains Rosh Hashanah's unique character. The Zohar speaks of two types of judgment: Din HaKasheh (strict judgment - do we serve God purely because He wants us to) and Din HaRachamim (merciful judgment - do we simply do more mitzvos than aveiros). Rosh Hashanah operates on one fundamental question: Have we fulfilled the purpose of creation by proclaiming God as our king? The judgment isn't about individual sins but about our overall relationship. "Lo hibit aven b'Yaakov" - God doesn't look at our individual failings on this day. If we have more mitzvos than aveiros, it demonstrates we've submitted to His authority more than we've rebelled - we've made Him our king. This is why it's a day of friendship and joy despite being judgment day. The Rambam (רמב"ם)'s explanation of shofar as both coronation and wake-up call now makes sense. The shofar proclaims God's kingship while simultaneously awakening us to remember that this coronation is our entire purpose in creation. His instruction to view ourselves as half-meritorious, half-liable doesn't mean we can sin freely, but that we must constantly ask: Am I in a state of submitting to His authority? This transforms our understanding of the entire day. We stand before God not as criminals before a harsh judge, but as children before a loving father who judges us on whether we've recognized His kingship. The happiness of Rosh Hashanah comes from realizing this is all He asks of us - not perfection in every detail, but submission to His sovereignty born of relationship and love.
An introduction to the first chapter of Ramchal's Derech HaShem, covering six fundamental principles about God's nature and existence, including the difference between emunah (internalization) and yedi'ah (knowledge).
An introductory class to studying the Ramchal's Derech Hashem, covering the author's life, his major works (Mesilat Yesharim, Derech Hashem, Da'at Tevunot), and the philosophical foundations that will guide the series.
Rosh Hashanah liturgy and laws
Sign in to access full transcripts
