An exploration of why non-Jews specifically challenge the mitzvah (מצוה) of Parah Adumah rather than questioning our commitment of na'aseh v'nishma, and what this reveals about the fundamental nature of our relationship with Hashem (ה׳).
The shiur begins with a fundamental question about Parshas Parah: why do the nations of the world specifically challenge Klal Yisrael about Parah Adumah, asking "why should you do it?" when they could ask a much more fundamental question about na'aseh v'nishma - our commitment to accept the Torah (תורה) before even knowing what it contains. The speaker explores the distinction between these two challenges through the lens of a Gemara (גמרא) in Shabbos (שבת), where a Tzaduki criticizes the Jewish people as "am pachaz" (hasty nation) for saying na'aseh before nishma. The answer lies in understanding what na'aseh v'nishma represents: it reflects our trust in Hashem (ה׳)'s love for us, similar to trusting a doctor's prescription because we believe in both their expertise and their care for our wellbeing. The nations can understand this trust-based relationship, even if they don't share it. However, Parah Adumah presents a different challenge - it's a mitzvah (מצוה) where Hashem explicitly says "gezeiras melech hi l'fanai" (it is a decree of the King before Me), meaning we must do it simply because He commands it, not because of any discernible benefit. The speaker explains that even Shlomo HaMelech, the wisest of all men, declared "amarti echkam v'hi rechoka mimeni" - he thought he could understand Parah Adumah but found it beyond human comprehension. The resolution is profound: Parah Adumah represents the fundamental basis of all mitzvos - that we perform them because we are Hashem's servants (avadim), and through this servitude we achieve dvekut (closeness) with Him. All other benefits and reasons for mitzvos flow from this primary relationship of submission to Divine will. This concept of willing servitude leading to ultimate spiritual benefit is something the nations cannot grasp, as their relationship with the Divine is limited to the seven Noahide laws - essentially "don't mess up the world order." They lack the framework for understanding a relationship based on dvekut and spiritual accomplishment through submission. The Tzaduki's challenge is different - they question the very foundation of trusting Hashem in the first place, viewing it as a business relationship where each party should look out for their own interests rather than trusting in Divine benevolence.
Parshas Parah
Sign in to access full transcripts
