נצבים
Dedicate a Shiur in Parshas Nitzavim
L'ilui nishmas a loved one. In honor of a simcha or yahrzeit. As a zechus for a refuah sheleimah. Your dedication helps carry Rabbi Zweig's Torah to learners around the world.
59 shiurim for Parshas Nitzavim
Why does the Rambam place the laws of bechirah in Hilchos Teshuvah rather than among the fundamentals of faith? The shiur develops a chiddush that bechirah means we literally create ourselves through our choices - choosing good makes us good people, not just earns reward. This creative power explains why the same force that creates can also recreate through teshuvah.
Why does Nitzavim list roshei ha'shevatim before zekeinim—leaders before scholars? The shiur argues that entering into this covenant is a political act, requiring not just Torah knowledge but the capacity to build institutions. Those with financial and organizational responsibility (roshei ha'shevatim) lead; those who take achrayus for infrastructure—yeshivos, economy, Beis Hamikdash—come first in creating Malchus Hashem.
Why does Rosh Hashanah precede Yom Kippur, judging us before we've confessed or repented? The shiur develops a fundamental yesod from Yishmael's story: Rosh Hashanah judges not our past behavior but our present willingness to coronate Hashem as king going forward. When Yishmael—guilty of idolatry, adultery, and attempted murder—called out to "Elokim" (not just God but King), he became a tzaddik in that moment, meriting a miracle despite his horrific past.
How does genuine internal change in a parent influence children? The Baal HaTurim's remez for Elul in the pasuk "Umal Hashem es levavcha v'es levav zarecha" teaches that only what we truly feel—not mechanical actions done from obligation—transfers to the next generation. When a parent's heart is genuinely transformed, that itself becomes "levav zarecha," extending naturally to their children's hearts.
Why does Rashi render 'rosheichem l'shivteichem' as 'your heads to your tribes' rather than simply 'heads of your tribes'? The phraseology indicates that true leadership requires providing vision and direction, not just holding authority. This yesod applies directly to marriage and parenting—a husband must have clear life vision that shapes his household, since children develop values through inspirational leadership rather than mere rules.
Why does saying Vayechulu on Shabbos make us partners with God, while saying it Wednesday has no such effect? The shiur develops that Shabbos gives us the unique power to actually empower the Divine through speech. This empowerment extends to blessing children and strengthening marriages on Shabbos in ways impossible during the week.
What does it mean to make God king on Rosh Hashanah when He doesn't need our validation? Free will is not merely choosing right from wrong but the power to create reality. When we coronate God as king, we actually empower Him to function as lord of the world—the ultimate expression of love and the true basis of forgiveness on the Day of Judgment.
Why does the covenant at Nitzavim highlight shotrim (enforcers) alongside Torah leaders? The shiur develops that shotrim create an atmosphere of "thou shall not" rather than punishing transgressors. This reveals the Torah's optimum system where compliance comes from moral teaching, not consequences.
Why does the Torah use the double expression 'emor v'amarta' when commanding Moshe to speak to the Kohanim? The shiur develops that true communication means discovering something unique about the person you're addressing that empowers them. This transforms how we deliver difficult messages - even restrictions must make people feel elevated rather than limited.
Why does the pasuk in Nitzavim say Hashem will perform surgery on "your heart and the heart of your children"? True teshuvah is not merely fixing personal behavior but recognizing mitzvos as a cosmic mission—understanding that you are part of Hashem's government, working to run the world His way. A person who views teshuvah only as cleaning up his own act has not yet grasped that mitzvos are a tikkun olam responsibility that must be transmitted to the next generation.
Why does Tehillim 81 define Rosh Hashanah as the "hidden moon holiday"? The shiur develops the principle that the moon's diminishment teaches the foundation of malchus: serving Hashem means receiving exactly what's needed for the job, without self-aggrandizement or feeling entitled as "part of management." This yesod explains Parshas Nitzavim's warning against those who hear the bris yet think "b'shirirus libi elech"—a dangerous mindset that confuses spiritual elevation with ownership rights.
What's the difference between Hashem speaking a promise and swearing an oath? The shiur draws a fundamental distinction: dibbur creates a right that can be forfeited if the recipient becomes unworthy or uninterested. A shevuah means Hashem commits to orchestrating circumstances so the promise can still be fulfilled.
What is the true purpose of vidui (confession) if it's not about guilt or self-punishment? Rabbi Zweig reveals that vidui means "I want you to continue talking to me" - it's about maintaining and advancing our relationship with Hashem. The goal isn't to beat ourselves up and feel clean, but to communicate openly so the relationship can grow stronger.
Why do we rip our clothes when witnessing a Jew die? Rashi compares it to watching a sefer Torah burn because every Jew embodies Torah—not as something learned externally, but as their essential identity. The pasuk "ki karov eilecha hadavar b'ficha u'vilvavcha la'asos" means Torah is embedded in our genetic code; doing mitzvos flows naturally from who we truly are.
Why does Torah call Rosh Hashanah a day of love when it feels oppressive? The shiur explains that God owns us absolutely but chooses to limit Himself. When we blow shofar and coronate Him as King, He abandons His ownership rights and grants us due process in His court of justice.
Why can Yishmael be saved as a tzaddik despite past sins, while ben sorer umoreh is judged by his future? The shiur distinguishes two dimensions of teshuvah: kapara (fixing the past, requiring vidui, Yom Kippur, suffering) and becoming a tzaddik now (requiring only sincere commitment to act properly going forward). Rosh Hashanah judges basher hu sham—where you are headed—not where you have been, making the status of tzaddik accessible to anyone willing to commit to change.
Why does the Torah write "rosheichem shivteichem" instead of simply "roshei shivteichem"? Rashi reads it as "rosheichem l'shivteichem"—your heads according to your tribes—teaching that tribal heads held national positions, not merely state ones. This explains why they appear before the Zekeinim: they bore executive responsibility for all of Klal Yisrael, functioning as a twelve-member presidium with national authority.
Why is confession (vidui) the central prayer of the High Holy Days? The shiur develops a fundamental insight that vidui actually means "thank you" - gratitude for receiving mitzvos that are entirely for our benefit. This transforms teshuvah from self-flagellation into recognition that God has no agenda except our good.
Why does the covenant at Arvos Moav introduce a new form of arvus (mutual responsibility) when Klal Yisroel already accepted arvus at Har Sinai? The shiur develops the yesod that lo bashamayim hi marks the transfer of Torah ownership from Hashem to Klal Yisroel as a corporate entity—a partnership where each individual's actions reflect on the whole. This corporate arvus differs fundamentally from the individual responsibility to prevent sin taught in Parshas Bechukosai. The insight explains why the tochacha of Ki Savo (addressed to the nation as a political entity) is read before Rosh Hashanah, when we coronate Hashem as king over the goy Yisrael—not merely over individuals, but over a sophisticated, organized nation with infrastructure and leadership.
Why does the Torah link your teshuvah with your children's hearts (Nitzavim 30:6)? The Baal HaTurim's remez reveals that genuine ratzon only exists when you want it for your children too—otherwise, a lack remains in your own commitment. The pasuk's language (umal Hashem) teaches a second principle: true teshuvah begins when you separate who you are from what you desire, recognizing your choices are not your identity.
Why would Hashem threaten to kill Moshe's uncircumcised son on the way to Egypt when the child bore no responsibility? The Baal HaTurim's principle that milah is essential for closeness to Hashem reveals that a father's uncircumcised child creates a deficiency in the father's own milah status. Just as an uncircumcised child prevents one from eating Korban Pesach, it would have prevented Moshe from receiving prophecy—making the mission to redeem Israel impossible.
Why does the pasuk distinguish "befischa" (in your mouth) from "uvelevavcha" (in your heart)? Rashi identifies these as Torah shebichsav and Torah sheba'al peh. The Shelah's yesod explains: written Torah carries intrinsic kedushah in its words alone, earning reward even without understanding, while Oral Torah requires comprehension (lev=understanding) to fulfill the mitzvah at all.
Why does the Torah phrase it "your heads, your tribes" (Rosheichem Shivteichem) instead of simply "heads of your tribes"? The shiur develops the yesod that true leadership is not individual achievement but a reflection of the entire group's collective effort. Applied to families with exceptional children and corporate management alike, the principle teaches that leaders must attribute their success to those who support them.
Why does the Gemara say a beis din may beat someone for not doing mitzvos, yet the Rambam teaches that doing mitzvos without enthusiasm is worse than mocking them? The shiur develops the yesod that coercion creates resentment while education fosters understanding—the purpose of Elul is not external pressure but internal clarity about why mitzvos are good for us.
Why did Klal Yisrael accept Torah Shebichsav at Har Sinai but resist Torah Shebaal Peh until Purim? The shiur builds on the Midrash Tanchuma (Parshas Noach) that Torah Shebichsav means following Hashem's directives, while Torah Shebaal Peh demands taking personal responsibility—developing halacha, creating Torah, and owning the relationship. The curses of this week's parsha are not about the relationship failing; they are about us, showing that Hashem's entire demand—even the responsibility of Torah Shebaal Peh—is for our growth, not His need.
Does mouthing Torah words without understanding have value? The shiur draws on the Shalah's principle that Torah shebichsav has intrinsic holiness — even a child reciting Shema gains — while Torah sheba'al peh requires understanding. Rashi's peshat on "beficha uvilvavecha" emerges clearly: beficha refers to the mouth-level mitzvah of Written Torah, uvilvavecha to the understanding required for Oral Torah.
Why does the Torah write 'rosheichem shivteichem' instead of the simpler 'roshei shivteichem'? The awkward phrasing teaches that these weren't merely political heads of tribes, but leaders whose personalities molded their entire tribes into tzaddikim—paralleling the Gemara in Chulin that a righteous king makes all his servants righteous. Such transformative leaders rank even above the Sanhedrin in the covenant's hierarchy.
Why does the Rambam place the laws of free choice within Hilchos Teshuvah rather than Yesodei HaTorah? The shiur distinguishes between original bechirah (free will in creation) and post-sin bechirah - Hashem's gift allowing us to unilaterally reconnect and transform from mortal to immortal through choosing life and connection to Him.
Does reading Torah without understanding the words have any value? The Shelah HaKadosh distinguishes between Torah sheb'kesav and Torah sheb'al peh: written Torah retains value even without comprehension because the words themselves are holy, while oral Torah requires understanding to have meaning. This insight explains Rashi's puzzling commentary on 'in your mouth and in your heart.'
Why does the Torah command simcha on Rosh Hashanah when we're facing life-or-death judgment? The shiur develops a fundamental yesod: Hashem's entire system—including Rosh Hashanah judgment—is purely for our benefit, not His. The test of Avrohom at Lech Lecha reveals this axiom: we must internalize that mitzvos are inherently good for us, not God controlling or manipulating us for His agenda.
What makes teshuvah work overnight when the Rambam requires lengthy processes for most sins? The shiur develops a revolutionary understanding: teshuvah through bechirah creates immediate identity transformation, not just behavioral commitment. Torah study facilitates this identity change — the same power described in "lo bashamayim hi" where we become arbiters of truth.
Why did the Jewish people rebel despite having happiness, a glad heart, and material abundance? The Rambam reads "tachas asher lo avadta" as: we stopped serving Hashem *because* we had everything—fearing divine control rather than recognizing divine love. Rosh Hashanah demands we internalize that the entire Torah system exists solely for our benefit, not to control us.
Why does Parshas Nitzavim, filled with curses, serve as encouragement before Rosh Hashanah? The shiur distinguishes Torah Shebiksav (our self-completion) from Torah Shebe'al Peh (our relationship with Hashem). Nitzavim's threats are about preventing self-destruction—not about what we owe Him—and that's precisely the chizuk we need. Din on Rosh Hashanah isn't punishment for failing Him; it's His insistence that we not harm ourselves.
Why does Parshas Nitzavim place curses after promising eternal Jewish survival? The shiur develops a two-tier answer: the nation is guaranteed survival, but individuals can lose hope and act recklessly. A Jewish community must therefore ensure every individual Jew feels secure and supported. This principle—Kol Yisrael Areivim Zeh BaZeh—is the foundation of teshuvah and the entire avodah of Rosh Hashanah, which focuses not on personal salvation but on Hashem's malchus and the survival of His entire nation.
Why do we take on extra stringencies during Aseres Yemei Teshuva without committing to continue them afterward—isn't that being phony? The shiur develops a fundamental distinction: during these ten days we connect to God internally, through the godliness within ourselves, rather than externally. The practices we adopt (pas Yisroel, extra charity, greater care in mitzvos) aren't meant to impress God but to sensitize ourselves to our spiritual essence.
Why does the Gemara say to learn Torah purely out of love—then add, "But in the end, honor will come"? Rabbi Zweig develops the yesod that love, both of Hashem and in marriage, is not seeking ulterior gain but self-worth. The validation that comes from true connection *is* love. Elul is when Hashem removes barriers so we can feel that connection—entering Rosh Hashanah not in terror, but knowing He loves us and wants our cure, not our punishment.
Why does Hakhel mandate that non-Jews attend and that the king (not a sage) reads? The shiur develops a yesod that Hakhel defines the Jewish nation not merely as Torah learners but as the Aron HaTorah itself—bearers of keser Torah. This madrega transforms the person into a vessel of holiness and is a teshuvah greater than all korbanos. The message applies equally to bnei yeshiva and baalei batim: redefine who you are.
Why does Rambam place the laws of free choice within the laws of repentance? The shiur develops the principle that true teshuvah is not merely behavioral change but a fundamental identity transformation—thinking of oneself as a Ben Torah rather than a professional who does mitzvos. This mindset shift, which Torah tells us is "very close" (Devarim 30:14), makes behavioral change flow naturally and renders the mechanics of atonement almost unnecessary.
How can Rosh Hashanah be called a 'day of love' when it feels heavy with judgment, and why is there no vidui unlike Yom Kippur? The shiur reframes free will not as choosing between options, but as divine creative power to transform identity and literally make God king. This empowers us as active participants whose choices create reality rather than passive objects of judgment.
Why does Parshas Nitzavim establish a new covenant when earlier covenants already existed? The shiur builds a yesod that this covenant reorganizes the Jewish people into one interconnected entity — no longer separate individuals united under Moshe, but an indivisible corporate structure reflecting Hashem's unity. From this flows kol Yisrael areivim zeh bazeh and the power to bind future generations.
Why does the Rambam connect free choice (bechirah) specifically to teshuvah? The shiur develops that bechirah means more than the ability to choose actions—it's the power to choose our identity. Teshuvah works immediately not by erasing sins but by allowing us to redefine who we are, which transforms our relationship with Hashem instantly.
How can Rosh Hashanah be both a terrifying Day of Judgment and a day of love and friendship? The shiur resolves this paradox by showing that din (judgment) is actually the ultimate chesed - we have no inherent right to a day in court as created beings. The Divine judgment system reflects tremendous love, not adversity.
Why does the Torah place free will immediately after discussing repentance? The shiur reveals that free will means more than choosing our actions—it means we choose who we become. We are responsible not just for what we do, but for our very character traits, which makes genuine change (teshuvah) always possible.
Why does Rosh Hashanah coincide with the new moon when it's barely visible? The shiur connects Parshas Nitzavim's unusual language about standing "nitzavim" with the Talmudic story of the moon's complaint to God. True Jewish leadership requires taking less than one's full entitlement, focusing on mission over honor.
How does the covenant of Arvot Moav differ from earlier obligations? The shiur develops the yesod that this covenant created a new level of unity — not just working for the same Master, but collectively becoming a reflection of Hashem's presence. When Klal Yisrael embraces yichud Hashem as a shared vision rather than individual service, future generations become bound, teshuvah becomes natural, and mutual responsibility reaches the depth of "kol Yisrael areivim zeh bazeh."
Why didn't Moshe get credit for taking Yosef's bones out of Egypt, even though he did most of the work? The shiur explores the Midrash distinguishing between two dimensions of mitzvos: personal growth (tiferes la'oseha) versus communal repair (tikkun achlas hamedinas). Moshe acted as agent of Klal Yisrael to rectify the sale of Yosef—a communal kapara—so when Bnei Yisrael finished the burial in Shechem, the mitzvah was credited to them, not him.
Why does Hebrew use the verb 'kores' (to cut) when making a covenant, which seems to contradict the binding nature of a bris? The ancient ceremony involved cutting everyone else out to create an exclusive relationship where two incomplete halves merge into genuine oneness. This transforms how we understand Jewish marriage, communal responsibility, and why Jewish relationships often seem more demanding than mere partnerships.
Why does the Torah use the verb "kores" (to cut) when creating a covenant (bris)? The shiur develops a fundamental distinction: a bris is not a partnership of two complete entities but a merger—two halves becoming one whole. This yesod applies to marriage (where spouses become incomplete without each other), to our relationship with Hashem, and to Kol Yisrael Areivim Zeh Bazeh—explaining why another Jew's needs are literally my needs, not merely my responsibility.
Why do we resist doing teshuva so strongly? The Midrash reveals that Adam refused God's invitation to repent due to arrogance - he thought teshuva meant groveling for forgiveness. From Kayin's experience, Adam learned that teshuva isn't begging but earning entitlement through genuine transformation into a new person.
Why does the Torah use the word 'hain' when announcing Moshe's death? The shiur analyzes a midrash comparing this to a king who kills someone with their own gift. The word 'hain' creates absolute, irreversible knowledge of death - a punishment measure-for-measure because Moshe said 'hain lo ya'aminu li,' expressing absolute certainty about Israel's lack of faith.
Why does the Torah list "your heads, your tribes" separately instead of "heads of your tribes"? A head is not merely an administrator giving orders but an energy source that vitalizes those connected to him. The Arvos Moav covenant establishes communal responsibility because true leadership creates organic connection—when people draw energy from the same head, they become responsible for each other naturally, not by external imposition.
How can we break the vicious cycle of sin and repentance? The Midrash on "Vayelech Moshe" reveals that Moshe's final act was showing each Jew their unique ability (their "shem"). True criticism means empowering people by revealing what void they alone can fill. This was the moment Jews transitioned from dependence on Moshe's direct prophecy to taking responsibility for Torah themselves.
What does it mean that we are commanded to see God's "face" (re'os ponai) at the Beis Hamikdash, and why does the Rosh Hashanah liturgy reference Matan Torah? The shiur develops the concept that "panim el panim" means direct, personal interaction—not just performing mitzvos but experiencing a dynamic relationship. Rosh Hashanah creates that same face-to-face intimacy without needing to travel to Yerushalayim; Hashem comes to us ("Hashem ori"), transforming judgment into closeness.
What does it mean that Moshe praised God with the word 'hein' (behold) and received honor back through that same word? The shiur develops a profound understanding that 'hein' refers to clothing/dignity, showing how shamayim functions as God's levush (royal garment). When we recognize shamayim as God's kavod, this creates the pathway to genuine yiras shamayim.
Why does Parshas Nitzavim contain curses when we want a break before Rosh Hashanah? The Rambam's placement of free will in Hilchos Teshuvah reveals two types of repentance: undoing past actions versus accessing the part of ourselves that remains untouched by our deeds.
Why does the Torah emphasize that it's not in heaven or across the sea when these seem obvious? The shiur explores how these verses reference two earlier Torah receptions: Torah Sheba'al Peh (Oral Law) at Mount Sinai and Torah Shebichsav (Written Law) at Marah. Both elevated experiences carried spiritual dangers - arrogance from heavenly ascent and recklessness from crossing dangerous waters.
Why does the Torah list the covenant participants in such a specific order, with shotrim (enforcers) given surprising prominence? The shiur develops the idea that shotrim help people connect emotionally to what they intellectually know is right. This covenant differs from Sinai because it focuses on internalization rather than just acceptance.
What distinguishes the covenant in Nitzavim from previous covenants like Kabbalas HaTorah? The shiur develops that earlier covenants operated contractually - we accept Hashem's authority expecting comprehensible benefits in return. Nitzavim establishes absolute surrender without expectations, enabling true achdus since everyone relates to Hashem with identical total bitul rather than individual spiritual attainments.
What distinguishes the bris of Parshas Nitzavim from all previous covenants, including Matan Torah? This shiur develops the yesod that Nitzavim's bris establishes absolute hisbatlus — total self-nullification to Hashem — without any reciprocal obligation. Unlike the contractual nature of even naso v'nishma, this covenant creates pure achdus through recognizing that Hashem owes us nothing in return.
