An exploration of the Torah (תורה)'s laws regarding unintentional murder, cities of refuge, and the goel hadam, revealing how murder uniquely challenges belief in Divine Providence and requires special Divine intervention to demonstrate that God controls human destiny.
Rabbi Zweig analyzes the complex laws of murder in Parshas Mishpatim, beginning with the phenomenon that when someone commits unintentional murder, any Jewish person has the right to kill him, though he can escape to a city of refuge. This system appears primitive and inconsistent with normal Torah (תורה) jurisprudence, which requires two witnesses, warning, and a court of twenty-three judges. Here, only one witness suffices, and there's no formal trial. The perpetrator remains in the city of refuge until the Kohen Gadol dies, creating a seemingly arbitrary connection between the High Priest's death and the murderer's freedom. The Talmud (תלמוד) explains that when someone kills unintentionally, both the perpetrator and victim were murderers - God uses one murderer to kill another. This raises a fundamental theological problem: how can one person's free choice affect another's destiny? If I choose to murder you, and you don't deserve to die, how can my choice determine your fate? This would suggest God doesn't control the world. Rabbi Zweig argues that murder is uniquely devastating because it creates the impression that humans, not God, control destiny. Unlike other sins which are between man and God (bein adam l'Makom), murder appears to demonstrate that one person can choose another's fate, effectively denying Divine Providence. This is why murder requires special Divine intervention - God must demonstrate that He, not man, controls life and death. The cities of refuge (arei miklat) serve as rehabilitation centers, particularly the cities of the Levites. Shevet Levi represents total devotion to God, owning no land and having no material interests. The murderer must learn that everything comes from God, not human choice. The Kohen Gadol embodies this ideal most fully, representing complete nullification before the Divine. When he dies, the murderer's rehabilitation is complete. This explains why the goel hadam (blood avenger) system exists - it's not primitive vengeance, but God's way of demonstrating Divine control. The Rambam (רמב"ם) states that murder is worse than other capital crimes because it destroys society's peace (yishuv hashalom) by suggesting humans control others' destinies. The Torah guarantees Divine vengeance for murder through the phrase 'nokem dam avadav' - God will avenge His servants' blood. Rabbi Zweig connects this to Yaakov teaching Yosef about eglah arufah (the heifer whose neck is broken when a murder victim is found), suggesting this prepared Yosef to understand that even his brothers' intended harm was Divine orchestration. Similarly, the Holocaust challenged belief in God precisely because it appeared humans could determine others' fates on a massive scale. The Torah's response is that God will ultimately demonstrate His control through Divine vengeance, revealing that even evil people are merely instruments of Divine will.
An introduction to the first chapter of Ramchal's Derech HaShem, covering six fundamental principles about God's nature and existence, including the difference between emunah (internalization) and yedi'ah (knowledge).
An introductory class to studying the Ramchal's Derech Hashem, covering the author's life, his major works (Mesilat Yesharim, Derech Hashem, Da'at Tevunot), and the philosophical foundations that will guide the series.
Parshas Mishpatim 21:12-13
Sign in to access full transcripts
