Why does the Gemara (גמרא) derive minyan's ten-person requirement specifically from the evil spies rather than other groups of ten? The meraglim represent unified action toward a common goal, not mere cooperation for individual benefit. This reveals that tefillah b'tzibbur creates qualitatively different prayer where ten people request 'heal us' rather than 'heal me' — a unified voice with greater spiritual power.
This shiur examines the fundamental nature of minyan and community through the Gemara (גמרא)'s derivation of the ten-person requirement from the meraglim (spies). The Gemara learns from the verse 'ad mosai l'eidah harah hazos' (how long shall this evil community) that an eidah requires ten people, since there were ten evil spies. The speaker addresses a crucial question: why derive this specifically from the spies rather than other instances of ten people? The answer reveals a profound insight about the nature of community. The shiur distinguishes between two types of group activities. The first is when individuals with similar needs pool resources - like building a school where each parent contributes for their own child's benefit. This represents cooperation for individual gain, not true community. The second type, exemplified by the meraglim, involves unified action toward a common goal. The ten spies didn't each pursue individual agendas; they worked in concert to prevent entry into Eretz Yisrael. The word eidah derives from yi'ud (designation/relationship), indicating connection and unity of purpose. This understanding transforms our comprehension of tefillah b'tzibbur (communal prayer). When ten people pray together, they don't simply pray individually in proximity. Rather, they create a qualitatively different form of prayer where everyone requests the same thing. When saying 'refaeinu' (heal us), each person means 'us,' not 'me.' This unified request has greater spiritual power than individual prayers, similar to how politicians respond more to constituency groups than individuals. The quality of the minyan matters significantly. The Chasam Sofer notes that praying with talmidei chachamim creates an even higher level of communal prayer, as the group's spiritual stature elevates everyone's tefillah. The principle of 'b'rov am hadras melech' (in multitudes is the king's glory) applies not just to numbers but to the quality of participants. This understanding explains why certain prayers require minyan - they represent the community speaking with one voice, creating a 'davar shebikedushah' (matter of holiness) that individual prayer cannot achieve. The chazaras hashatz (repetition of Amidah) exemplifies this, with one person representing the unified voice of ten, while the silent Amidah represents ten people making identical requests.
Dedicate a Shiur in Aggadita
L'ilui nishmas a loved one. In honor of a simcha or yahrzeit. As a zechus for a refuah sheleimah. Your dedication helps carry Rabbi Zweig's Torah to learners around the world.
Up Next in this Series
How can speaking about land compare to lashon hara about a person? The spies exemplified how lashon hara distorts reality by taking true facts out of context, just as they reported constant funerals without noting that God was distracting inhabitants for their safety. This self-deception convinces speakers they're nobly 'telling truth' while actually living in a world of lies.
Why does the Torah write 'Bereishis bara Elokim' in a way that could grammatically suggest someone created God? The ambiguity is intentional, revealing that Israel (called 'reishis') participates in making God King through accepting His sovereignty. This partnership explains why we become God's 'mother' in the Gemara's reading of Shir HaShirim - we crown Him through 'na'aseh v'nishma.'
Gemara discussing 'ad mosai l'eidah harah hazos' and the derivation of minyan from the spies
Looking for the full transcript?
Become a member of the TUF Alumni Association for full access
Join the TUF Alumni AssociationAlready a member? Sign in
How could the spies, who were shotrei that sacrificed themselves for fellow Jews in Egypt, later terrorize the nation with their negative report? When people perform noble actions while harboring internal resentment, they create psychological pressure that explodes in the opposite direction. This explains why Dasan saved Jews but then attacked Moshe, and why the spies couldn't accept being powerless again in Israel despite Hashem's protection.
What does the Midrash mean by calling the Jewish people 'daughters of waves' - daughters of the outstanding patriarchs? The shiur develops a yesod distinguishing 'ben' (independent choice) from 'bas' (inherited patterns), revealing two types of teshuvah. Jews should return to Hashem instinctively through inherited spiritual patterns, not just through conscious deliberation.
