קהלת
kesuvim
Dedicate a Shiur in Sefer Koheles
L'ilui nishmas a loved one. In honor of a simcha or yahrzeit. As a zechus for a refuah sheleimah. Your dedication helps carry Rabbi Zweig's Torah to learners around the world.
78 shiurim for Koheles
Why does Koheles warn about crookedness that cannot be straightened, since teshuvah can fix any sin? Rashi explains that a parent who commits adultery resulting in a mamzer cannot fully repent, because genuine regret would mean wishing the child didn't exist. This reveals how parent-child bonds can actually impede complete teshuvah when the sin produces consequences we cannot emotionally reject.
Why was Jerusalem destroyed for lack of criticism when sinat chinam suggests people didn't get along well? The Rambam redefines tochacha as helping someone understand how their actions harm themselves, with the actual mitzvah being to guide them back to goodness. Jerusalem fell because without genuine care, criticism becomes attack rather than loving guidance.
When the Torah gives reasons for mitzvos, can someone claim the reason doesn't apply to them? Shlomo HaMelech correctly understood this principle but failed when applying it to himself - we cannot assess ourselves objectively despite being capable of objectivity about others. True wisdom requires trusted advisors who help us see our real character, not our self-deceptive version.
Why is lashon hara so devastating when it often involves telling the truth? The shiur shows that lashon hara implicitly lies about identity—suggesting 'this is who you are' rather than 'this is what you did.' In Western culture's perception-driven society, people internalize others' judgments and lose the self-esteem necessary for genuine teshuvah.
Why does Shlomo HaMelech say all worldly success is 'rei'us ruach' - it breaks a person? The shiur develops the principle that true anavah means recognizing achievements as simply how God made us, not indicators of personal worth. This allows enjoying success without anxiety about losing it and treating all people as genuine equals regardless of their circumstances.
Why does Koheles call human achievement 're'us ruach' - spirit-breaking? Success itself creates immediate anxiety about potential loss, which clouds judgment and leads to poor decisions. The spies exemplify this: righteous when chosen, their new leadership positions generated fear of losing status that corrupted their mission.
Why did God give the Torah to humans rather than angels who would never violate its commandments? The shiur develops that Torah is designed specifically for beings with human struggles and desires, offering transformation rather than mere rules. This recognition validates our nature while providing a path for genuine growth and relationship with God.
Why does Koheles describe the endless, futile cycles of nature and human life? The shiur reveals that Shlomo HaMelech is teaching us to focus on process over results - since all accomplishments are temporary, what matters is how we conduct ourselves. This yesod transforms chinuch and Torah study, making greatness accessible to anyone regardless of outcomes.
Why does Koheles open with 'divrei Kohelet' when Hebrew 'divrei' means criticism? The shiur reveals that effective criticism must simultaneously rebuke and comfort, like the dual meaning of the root 'daber.' The key insight: never criticize someone for personal offenses against you, only for how they treat others.
Why did Shlomo HaMelech despair over his life's work being inherited by his wicked son Rechavam? The shiur draws from Koheles 2:17-21 to argue that success cannot be measured by outcomes we don't control, since free will is fundamental to God's design. True success lies in creating optimal environments and being proper examples, not in numerical results or external appearances.
If both wise and wicked die, why choose wisdom? Shlomo HaMelech's answer reveals a dual perspective on creation: God creates for our benefit, but our purpose is to serve as His ambassadors. The difference between wise and wicked becomes clear only after death, when we can judge whether their conflicts promoted divine values or mere ego.
Why does Rashi translate 'foolishness' in Koheles 2:12 as 'wickedness,' and how is seeing consequences a character trait rather than intelligence? The shiur shows that self-destructive behavior stems from control issues - people refuse to accept statistical risks because acknowledging probability means admitting they're not in complete control. This yesod explains why sinat chinam and poor decisions flow from character flaws rather than mere stupidity.
Why did Shlomo conclude that even his wisely-designed utopian kingdom was empty and meaningless? The shiur develops the principle that life's purpose is personal development, not accumulating experiences or comfort. Using intelligence solely for entertainment and pleasure—rather than growth—represents a tragic waste of our God-given potential.
Why does Koheles describe chukim as "sechel" (foolishness) rather than using the Torah's positive terminology? The shiur develops Shlomo's psychological insight that authentic spiritual growth requires simultaneously embracing both our intellectual and physical nature while performing mitzvos that may appear foolish to others but are meaningful to ourselves, preventing us from "marketing" our religiosity for social approval.
Why did Shlomo HaMelech combine intellect, physical pleasure, and chukim after each approach individually failed? The shiur develops that humans must acknowledge both their physical nature and spiritual capacity simultaneously. Chukim (called "foolishness" here) teach us to act for internal meaning rather than external approval.
Why does prosperity often lead to spiritual decline? The shiur develops a principle that excessive closeness in any relationship - with God, spouses, or children - breeds familiarity that destroys respect. Love must always be grounded in maintaining appropriate boundaries and ongoing reverence, never taking blessing for granted.
Why does the Gemara in Brachos say that one who enjoys his own efforts is greater than one who fears Heaven? The shiur develops the principle that true pleasure comes from recognizing our accomplishments, not from what we acquire. This transforms spending from anxious consumption into celebration of potential fulfilled.
Why does Koheles say arrogant people receive the message that they are like animals who will die? The shiur develops a fundamental distinction between the Greek view of humans as rational animals versus the Torah view of humans as souls using bodies. When illness strikes, those who define themselves as bodies feel devastated by animal-like mortality, while those who see themselves as souls understand their essence is eternal.
Why does Koheles 3:16 describe corruption in the very place of justice? The most dangerous form of bribery involves presenting oneself as righteous, creating a system where everyone believes they're acting properly while corruption flourishes. This principle applies today when we use mitzvos as carte blanche — parents justifying harsh discipline as chinuch, or giving tochacha without proper intentions.
Why does God protect even wicked victims when righteous people pursue them? The principle "God seeks out the pursued" reveals that humans have no right to punish - only to defend themselves. Once we become the aggressor, we usurp God's role and face consequences, making "winning" in disputes spiritually dangerous.
Why does God hide our time of death from us when this creates contradictory impulses - living morally as if death is imminent while remaining productive as if we have years ahead? The shiur uses Rashi's dual explanation to show that death isn't intrinsic to our bodies, so we feel vibrantly alive and can build for the future. When facing imminent death, the perspective shifts entirely to emphasizing eternal existence rather than temporal endings.
Why do people sin when everything is ultimately temporary and will be lost? The issue isn't desire for pleasure but the need to control and rebel against divine authority. True satisfaction comes from redirecting this control impulse toward self-mastery rather than trying to control others.
Why does Koheles include exile among inevitable life cycles when it seems conditional on our sins? The principle of true protection requiring eventual independence explains both Yishmael's banishment and Jewish exile as divine mercy. Galus forces Jews to bond across ethnic divisions, while Yishmael gained the independence to develop away from destructive influences.
Why does the Gemara's advice for anxiety - "remove it from your heart" - seem overly simplistic? The shiur develops a yesod from Koheles that experiences must remain "eis" (momentary) rather than becoming life-defining. The first mitzvah to the Jewish people - freeing Hebrew slaves - teaches this principle: learn from difficult experiences without being overwhelmed by them.
Why does Torah criminal law make conviction nearly impossible, requiring two witnesses, prior warning, and immediate execution of the crime? The shiur reveals that Jewish law prioritizes moral education over punishment, teaching 'don't do wrong' rather than 'don't get caught.' This principle transforms parenting from consequence-management to raising children who internalize right and wrong.
Why does Rashi read Koheles 3:1's "time to give birth" as simply referring to pregnancy's nine-month duration? The shiur argues this teaches that God gives preparation time requiring active management rather than reactive responses. Just as people procrastinate because they lack inner strength to act independently, Jewish life demands proactive decision-making about values and challenges rather than following social trends or "shooting from the hip."
Why does Koheles speak of both zman (designated time) and eis (present moment) in spiritual matters? The shiur develops that zman represents God's invitation while eis represents our response, and their intersection creates moed - actual relationship rather than mere spiritual exercise. True avodah requires divine partnership, just as bris milah needed God's command because covenants cannot be unilateral.
Why should we not rejoice in wealth, yet the Talmud treats stealing even a penny as equivalent to murder? The shiur resolves this through two competing philosophies: Esav's "I have more than I need" treats money as personal pleasure, while Yaakov's "I have everything" sees money as a divine test of moral choice. Theft is severe because it removes someone's ability to exercise these divinely-appointed choices, not because it reduces physical comfort.
Is having many children always a mitzvah, even when parents can't raise them properly? The shiur argues that pru urvu requires quality parenting, not just procreation, citing cases where gedolim avoided having children rather than raise them poorly. The pre-flood generation's error was treating children as extensions of themselves rather than separate beings needing moral development.
Why does Koheles 4:15 suddenly mention 'all the living' and 'the second child'? The shiur reveals two distinct types of yetzer hara: pre-flood humanity sought control and dominance (seen in robbery for tiny amounts), while post-flood generations seek pleasure. This distinction transforms how we address challenging behavior - pleasure-seekers respond to consequences, while control-seekers need to understand that rules benefit them.
Why does the yetzer hara seem present in the womb if it only comes at birth? The shiur identifies two distinct types: one driven by pleasure that exists from birth, and Satan-type rebellion against control that emerges when authority feels arbitrary. Understanding this distinction prevents triggering self-destructive behaviors in chinuch by maintaining respect while setting boundaries.
Why does God accept Moshe' argument that destroying the Jewish people would make Him appear weak to the nations? The shiur develops the concept of "second level communication" - after Sinai, God chose to work through the Jewish people as partners, so their failure reflects on His ability by design. This yesod reframes how spouses should communicate: presenting desires as information rather than commands, preserving dignity while building true partnership.
Why does Koheles say the fool "eats his flesh" rather than simply starving? The shiur reveals that avoiding the pain of unfulfillment drives more behavior than pursuing gain - explaining why people choose riskier robbery over theft, and why happiness depends on realizing potential rather than absolute achievement.
Why does Koheles condemn competition when it produces excellent results and innovation? The shiur distinguishes between competing for excellence versus competing for honor and recognition. When professional or religious achievement becomes primarily about prestige rather than developing God-given talents, even mitzvos become tools for ego rather than genuine growth.
Why are Kohanim forbidden from cemeteries when the dead possess greater spiritual power than the living? The prohibition teaches that our mission is bringing God into this world, not escaping to His world. The dead are "greater" because they achieved actualization of their earthly accomplishments, not because they accessed higher spiritual realms.
Why does Koheles describe oppression as having no comforters, and what drives bullying behavior? The shiur analyzes the Torah's laws of oshek to show that some sins aim not at acquiring wealth but at demeaning others. This explains modern bullying as stemming from inner emptiness in a consumption-focused society, where people lack the fulfillment of meaningful work.
Why does the Rambam cite two different sources for building the Beis Hamikdash - one from Terumah and another from Re'eh? The Mikdash served dual functions: divine service (relating to Hashem) and national unity (the pilgrimage gatherings). This explains why the Rambam places the mitzvah in both Hilchos Beis Habechira and Hilchos Melachim - and why our homes must embody both aspects today.
Why do Jews give money for Chanukah while others give presents? The distinction reflects two opposing philosophies: Esav's "I have much" treats money as personal reward, while Yaakov's "I have everything" sees it as divine responsibility. Giving children money teaches judgment and accountability, while presents simply convey affection without developing character.
Why does Rashi read "one who loves money will not be satisfied" as meaning he won't even spend money? The shiur develops Rashi's insight that people who define themselves by net worth cannot spend because every expenditure diminishes their identity. Only those with genuine self-worth (built through personal effort) can enjoy their wealth freely.
Why doesn't God punish evildoers immediately and directly? Koheles 5:7 reveals that delayed or indirect punishment shows consequences flow from harmful actions themselves, not divine anger at disobedience. This principle transforms parenting: rules must clearly benefit the child's development, not parental convenience or ego.
Why does the Talmud say that one who breaks vows will see family members die? The shiur explains this isn't about divine punishment but about emotional destruction - when we break promises to spouses or children, we kill their dignity and self-worth. True marriage requires treating each other as independent people deserving respect, not as appendages of ourselves.
Why does Koheles warn against delaying vows when the real problem seems to be not fulfilling them at all? The shiur develops the principle that society's foundation depends on precise reliability - being late with commitments destroys social trust just as much as breaking them entirely. This explains why the wicked aren't necessarily liars but live in the delusion that good intentions equal action.
Why does Koheles connect excessive speech with dreams when warning about the dangers of too much talking? The shiur reveals that sicha doesn't mean ordinary speech but rather 'conversation that promotes growth' - like vegetation sprouting from earth. Women received nine measures of this ability because nurturing each person's unique potential, rather than imposing our own agendas, represents the Torah's ideal for relationships and parenting.
Why would prosperous people before the flood think God wouldn't punish them? The shiur develops a yesod that they believed God created humans for His own glory and therefore needed impressive giants for His reputation. God deliberately made humans weak and dependent to demonstrate that creation is entirely for our benefit, not His - a principle that transforms how we approach parenting and all relationships.
Why does Kohelet suggest that seeing wealth is better than physical pleasures? The shiur develops a revolutionary yesod: material pleasures aren't tests to endure but divine gifts that develop our capacity for eternity. Wealth transforms our self-perception of world impact, preparing us for immortal existence when channeled properly rather than pursued as mere luxury.
What makes coveting worse than other sins like idolatry or Sabbath violation? The shiur develops the yesod that lo sachmod attacks the person, not just their property, representing ultimate egocentricity that makes oneself God of the universe. Honoring parents through personal service creates healthy dependence that prevents this destructive mentality.
How could the holiest generation fall to Baal Peor, an idol worshipped through degrading acts? The shiur reveals that excessive religious pressure triggers psychological defense mechanisms where people degrade themselves to lower expectations and create excuses for failure. This explains why overpressured children often turn to self-destructive behaviors as pressure release valves.
Why couldn't King Shlomo understand the red heifer's paradox - that it purifies the impure while making the pure person impure? The shiur reframes chukim not as arbitrary divine commands but as expressions of love we don't yet grasp. Death itself follows this pattern: God created mortality not as punishment but as His mechanism to reconnect us to eternal life despite our sins.
What does Koheles mean by 'don't be overly righteous'? Using Saul's misplaced mercy toward Amalek as the paradigm, the shiur develops the principle that compassion toward the spiritually disconnected reveals disconnection within oneself. This explains why such misguided compassion inevitably leads to cruelty toward the truly deserving.
Why can you rent a car for money but not charge interest on a loan? Money has no intrinsic value - it's pure potential that only gains worth through the borrower's wisdom and effort. Charging interest therefore claims ownership over another person's mental faculties, which the Torah prohibits as a form of enslavement.
Why does Koheles 7:10 call asking why earlier generations had better circumstances an unwise question? Comparison-based thinking destroys personal growth by making others our standard rather than measuring ourselves against our own potential. The shiur connects this to Miriam and Aharon's lashon hara against Moshe, showing that such speech represents spiritual suicide by choosing stagnation over the challenge of becoming who we can uniquely be.
What connects all the characteristics Koheles attributes to a ksil - anger, putting others down, and asking foolish questions? The shiur identifies the common thread as a control syndrome, where the fool believes he owns his world rather than recognizing God's ultimate authority. This lens explains the puzzling connection between withholding gifts from kohanim and the sotah case - both stem from inappropriate attempts to control others.
Why did Elisha ben Abuyah, raised to learn Torah, become irreligious? The Midrash blames his father's selfish motivations, but this contradicts the Rambam's teaching that external motivations lead to pure intentions. The resolution shows that abused children cannot transcend ulterior motives because emotional pain blocks their ability to enjoy learning itself, making parental love the prerequisite for spiritual growth.
How can harsh criticism confuse even a wise leader like Moshe Rabbeinu? Using Koheles 7:7 and Rashi's interpretation, the shiur explains that wisdom means maintaining an objective, theocentric perspective rather than adopting critics' subjective viewpoints. Even when gathering all perspectives and feeling others' pain, a leader must resist the kesil's self-centered lens that defines reality only by personal impact.
Why does Kohelet contrast wise people who focus on death with fools who focus on celebrations? The shiur distinguishes three types of fools, focusing on the ksil who prioritizes societal comfort over growth. Datan and Aviram exemplify this mindset - even their criticism of Moshe was factually correct, but they missed that increased difficulty was preparation for receiving Torah.
Why does Koheles say it's better to attend funerals than weddings, and how can Rashi's explanation about reciprocal benefit align with chesed shel emes? The shiur distinguishes two types of chesed: expansive kindness that builds relationships, and self-diminishing personal service that imitates God's tzimtzum. At funerals one performs both types, making it superior to weddings where only expansive chesed occurs.
Why does the Mishna say a good name (shem tov) surpasses the three crowns of Torah, priesthood, and kingship? The crown of shem tov represents actualizing potential rather than receiving gifts - it's what you accomplish with your talents. This principle transforms education: true Torah chinuch develops children's thinking and character, not just behavioral compliance.
Why couldn't Moshe and Shlomo understand divine justice when later sages could explain it theologically? The concealment isn't about justice but about relationship - we cannot tell if good or bad events reflect God's approval or disapproval. This deliberate ambiguity preserves authentic moral choice by preventing us from becoming mere approval-seekers rather than genuine moral agents.
Why does Koheles praise happiness through eating and drinking, and how does Rashi connect dissatisfaction to robbery? The shiur develops a yesod that happiness depends on viewing possessions as gifts from God rather than entitlements. When we feel entitled, we cannot experience gratitude and eventually rationalize taking from others who have what we think we deserve.
Why does Koheles 8:5 state seemingly obvious truths about mitzvos and divine judgment? The answer lies in how wicked people exploit the parent-child relationship with God, reasoning that like indulgent parents, God won't ultimately destroy His children. However, divine commandments function as life-giving principles - violating them leads to self-destruction, not divine punishment.
Why does Koheles warn against trying to get away from God when it seems impossible? The shiur reveals that divine presence varies by location - some places feel closer to God while cities can feel godless. However, shalom bayis creates a dwelling place for divine presence anywhere, making marital harmony more important than geographical holiness when choosing where to live.
Why must Jews obey secular government while maintaining religious obligations? Chananiah, Mishael and Azariah's response to Nevuchadnezzar reveals that human authority is legitimate only when it doesn't contradict divine commands. This principle transforms parenting—children should follow parents not 'because I said so' but because parents serve as conduits to transcendent values and spiritual purpose.
When must we obey kings and parents, and when may we resist? The shiur builds on Rashi's reading of Koheles 8:2 to show that legitimate authority comes only when leaders direct us toward God's values. Parents demanding obedience 'because I said so' forfeit their authority just like Nevuchadnetzar did when commanding idolatry.
Why does halacha require judges to seek compromise even after determining the correct ruling? True wisdom involves "pesher" - not giving up principles but finding how different roles complement each other toward unified purpose. Families thrive when members understand they're serving shared divine goals rather than competing for limited resources.
Why is wisdom better than weapons when the verse could advocate for justified self-defense? The pasuk teaches that while fighting abuse is legitimate, choosing peace when possible creates deeper connection to God and community. This distinction between Greek emphasis on personal fulfillment versus Jewish priority on relationship explains why Matan Torah emphasized divine connection over legal contract.
Why don't the wise always have bread or the strong always win wars, as Koheles 9:11 observes? Success belongs entirely to God, not to human ability or effort. Our job is developing our capacities to the maximum while recognizing that whether those efforts translate to actual success remains God's decision alone.
Why does Koheles call Torah study, marriage, and work all forms of 'seeing life'? The shiur develops that these three activities share a unique power to redefine identity through bechirah - not just choosing actions, but choosing to become someone new. True marriage means internalizing your spouse's worldview, meaningful work actualizes your destined identity, and Torah transforms your essence.
How can uncertainty about death's timing elevate our spiritual service rather than just create anxiety? The shiur develops Rashi's king's party parable from Koheles to show that believing each day might be our last transforms routine mitzvos into defining moments of eternal significance. This explains why tzadikim are described as living "days and years" - they treat each day as a final opportunity for connection to God.
Why does Koheles 9:7 speak of eating and drinking with joy after God has approved our deeds? Two contrasting Midrashim about divine forgiveness reveal that true teshuva restructures obligations rather than erasing them completely. This maintains human dignity by requiring meaningful contribution within one's abilities - a principle with applications to chinuch and social policy.
Why do righteous and wicked people often face similar fates in life? The shiur develops a yesod that God refuses to use obvious consequences as behavioral controls, preferring to develop genuine moral reasoning over mere compliance. This principle transforms our approach to chinuch: developing children's understanding rather than controlling behavior through consequences creates thinking human beings, not well-trained robots.
Why does God need angels to report on human behavior if He's omniscient? The shiur reveals that God deliberately limits His knowledge when functioning as King rather than Creator, making divine judgment meaningful. This tzimtzum explains why Rosh Hashanah requires prosecuting angels, defending advocates, and our active proclamation of merits before the heavenly court.
Why does Koheles 10:19 emphasize working to afford proper celebrations with food and wine rather than accepting poverty? The shiur shows that wedding celebrations represent more than personal joy — they announce the couple's entry into community responsibility. Like a king serving subjects, newlyweds demonstrate through hospitality that their household will serve others, not just themselves.
Why do people procrastinate when it logically creates more anxiety and worse results? Using Bilam's story and Hillel's teaching in Avos, the shiur argues that procrastination stems from internal conflict - we delay tasks until external pressure forces action. The solution is developing genuine internal motivation rather than relying on external rewards.
Why do we procrastinate despite knowing it creates anxiety and makes tasks harder? Laziness stems from doing things we don't truly want to do, forcing us to create external pressure to motivate ourselves. The solution is internalizing that what we're doing—especially Torah learning—is genuinely for our own benefit and fulfillment.
Why does Koheles describe foolish speech as progressing from self-destruction to hurting others? Rashi's distinction between giving advice versus persuading reveals that wise communication empowers others to make independent decisions, while foolish communication seeks control through manipulation. This yesod transforms how we approach parenting and marriage.
Why do people speak lashon hara if it brings no pleasure? The shiur builds on the Gemara in Erchin's snake analogy to show that lashon hara alleviates spiritual pain from the gap between our potential and achievement. The healthy solution is channeling our need to affect others into positive action rather than destructive speech.
How can one small foolish act outweigh all wisdom and honor, as Koheles 10:1 describes? The shiur develops a chiddush that wickedness isn't determined by mathematical sin-ratios, but by self-destructive behavior that severs one's relationship with God. When someone destroys themselves, they declare independence from divine authority, creating license for unlimited wrongdoing.
What does it mean to "cast your bread upon the waters" (Koheles 11:1)? True chesed means investing in people without maintaining control or expecting gratitude, rather than giving with strings attached. When we help others as investors rather than creditors, we empower their growth and earn a genuine share in their success.
