Vayigash: The Yehuda-Yosef Struggle and Rectifying Adam HaRishon's Sin

Rabbi Zweig opens with a fundamental question about Parshas Vayigash: What do Yosef and Yehuda actually want? When confronted with the goblet in Binyamin's sack, Yehuda offers all twelve brothers as slaves—including Binyamin. Yet Yosef refuses, insisting he wants only Binyamin while the others go free. If Yosef's goal was simply to have Binyamin, he already achieved it when Yehuda made his offer. And if Yehuda's goal was to save Binyamin, he already conceded him. What, then, is the basis of their struggle? The answer lies in understanding two fundamentally different visions for how Klal Yisrael would descend to Egypt. Both knew from the Bris Bein HaBesarim that the Jewish people were destined to be enslaved in a foreign land for four hundred years. Yehuda has no problem with all twelve brothers going down as slaves to fulfill this covenant—such a decree from Heaven would not violate his guarantee to Yaakov, since guarantees only cover what is humanly preventable. But for Yosef, their descent as slaves to fulfill an ancient covenant would mean they are NOT coming down as fulfillment of his dreams, in which his family bows to him of their own compulsion. Yosef needs his father to come down because Yosef is forcing him to come—by holding Binyamin hostage and thereby compelling Yaakov to descend. Only then do his dreams come true. Yehuda, however, cannot allow Binyamin to be separated from the brothers, as his guarantee to Yaakov was fundamentally about preserving the unity and destiny of Klal Yisrael as a complete entity.