Rabbi Zweig addresses the apparent contradiction between serving God out of love versus the reward-and-punishment focus of Rosh Hashanah, offering a profound insight into the nature of divine love and proper motivation for mitzvah (מצוה) observance.
This Rosh Hashanah shiur to lawyers explores three fundamental questions about Jewish spiritual life. First, Rabbi Zweig addresses why Rosh Hashanah feels heavy and oppressive when Judaism should inspire love of God. Second, he examines the apparent contradiction between the holiday's focus on reward and punishment versus the Talmudic teaching that one should not serve God for reward. Third, he grapples with how reward can simultaneously be the foundational axiom of Judaism while being forbidden as a motivation for service. The resolution begins with a careful analysis of Rashi (רש"י)'s commentary on loving God from Parshas Shema. Rashi defines love as serving without intention of wealth, position, or recognition, but concludes 'don't worry, all the rewards will come.' This seeming contradiction reveals a profound insight: serving someone while expecting no response is not love but self-destruction. Rabbi Zweig explains that idol worship (avodah zarah) literally means serving an 'estranged' god - one who doesn't respond to his worshippers. True love requires knowing the beloved will respond, but without creating an obligation. The distinction is crucial: expecting a response because someone cares about you differs fundamentally from demanding payment owed. In healthy relationships - whether marital, parental, or divine - one gives expecting reciprocation based on love, not contractual obligation. Parents who sacrifice everything for ungrateful children, or people who pursue unresponsive partners, are engaging in self-destruction, not love. Applying this to divine service, Jews must know God will reward them (the foundational axiom), but serve Him without demanding payment owed. God cannot 'owe' us anything since He owns all existence. Rosh Hashanah judgment represents God fulfilling His promises out of love, not settling debts. Even apparent punishments reflect divine involvement and caring - getting involved in someone's problems demonstrates greater love than simply doing nice things for them. This understanding transforms Rosh Hashanah from a heavy day of accounting to a celebration of relationship. It's not 'paycheck Friday' but an opportunity to experience God's loving involvement in our lives. The day sets the tone for year-round service performed with joy, knowing we're in reciprocal relationship with a caring God. Both reward and correction stem from divine love and involvement. The shiur concludes with practical applications, including discussion of historical tragedies like the Holocaust and contemporary challenges to Jewish identity, always returning to the theme that divine involvement - whether pleasant or difficult - demonstrates ultimate care and concern for our spiritual development.
Analysis of the Mishnah's laws regarding when to bring the charoset, matzah, and other Seder foods to the table, focusing on the dispute between Rashbam and Tosafos about whether the table is brought before or after karpas.
An exploration of how marriage resolves the fundamental tension of "Ein shnei malachim mishtamshim b'keser echad" (two kings cannot share one crown), using the story of Vashti and Achashverosh to illuminate the cosmic relationship between Hashem and Klal Yisrael.
Parshas Shema, Rashi's commentary on loving God
Sign in to access full transcripts
